Eternal Scrutiny: Merillat's Continual Critique of Coaches, Even Amidst Triumphs
James Merillat's recent piece on Denversports.com doesn't pull any punches in his critique of Jared Bednar and Michael Malone's coaching abilities. However, while Merillat raises some valid points, his analysis overlooks crucial coaching adjustments that have propelled the Avalanche and Nuggets through challenging playoff moments.
He also consistently praises Tampa Bay Lightning coach Jon Cooper for his “frequent deep playoff runs” - despite two consecutive first round exits and having the NHL leader in points. How about a little love for Bednar and Malone? A few regular season losses to end the year and you’re running for the hills. Why?
Merillat's original assessment in his article focuses heavily on the Avalanche's 7-0 defeat against the Jets and the Nuggets' collapse against the Spurs. While these losses are undeniably disappointing, Merillat fails to acknowledge the strategic adaptations made by Bednar and Malone after these games. And let me tell you - when the games are most important, these coaches have seemed to rise to the occasion.
Consider Malone's strategic maneuvers in Game 1 and 2 of the Lakers series. His decision to switch Gordon onto AD disrupted the opponent's rhythm, showcasing his ability to adapt in real-time (in game 2 Davis was on fire - when Malone adjusted his last bucket was with 7:15 in the 3rd quarter). Additionally, Bednar's coaching expertise was evident in the Avalanche's rebound after the devastating 7-6 loss. The team's fiercely competitive performance in the subsequent game highlighted Bednar's astute analysis and strategic adjustments.
But let's not overlook the broader context. Bednar has steered the Avalanche to an impressive seven consecutive postseason berths (yes - that’s the most in the NHL), demonstrating consistency and resilience. Similarly, Malone has led the Nuggets to six straight playoff appearances, culminating in a championship title last year. Such sustained success is a testament to the coaching acumen of both individuals.
Well, he may say their 2021 and 2022 losses were “disappointing” - how can you say that with a straight face knowing that Murray didn’t play? Have you watched this team at full strength? Jokic is the MVP, and he’s why this team is always around in the playoffs. But Murray’s performances are the difference between a playoff team and a championship team.
It’s my opinion that the recent performances of both teams underscore the pivotal role Bednar and Malone play in their success. Bednar's faith in Georgiev and belief in Middlestadt have paid dividends (despite the trade deadline critiques of others at Denversports.com), while Malone's tough decision to play Murray in Game 5 proved instrumental in the Nuggets advancing to the second round.
While Merillat's critique raises valid concerns, it's crucial to acknowledge the strategic ingenuity and resilience of Bednar and Malone. As the postseason progresses, it's these coaching adjustments that will continue to shape the fortunes of the Avalanche and Nuggets, ensuring they remain formidable contenders on the brink of playoff success.
